Home » changement d'époque - changements de cap »changeons de lunettes »les technologies du changement » Currently Reading:

Studying Ethical Questions as the Brain’s Black Box Is Unlocked

In a world of proliferating professions, S. Matthew Liao has a singular title: neuroethicist. Dr. Liao, 40, the director of the bioethics program at New York University, deploys the tools of philosophy, history, psychology, religion and ethics to understand the impact of neuroscientific breakthroughs.

You’re a philosopher by training. How did philosophy lead to neuroethics?

Mine’s the typical immigrant’s story. My family moved to Cincinnati from Taiwan in the early 1980s. Once here, my siblings gravitated towards the sciences. I was the black sheep. I was in love with the humanities. So I didn’t go to M.I.T. — I went to Princeton, where I got a degree in philosophy. This, of course, worried my parents. They’d never met a philosopher with a job.

Do you have any insight on why scientific careers are so attractive to new Americans?

You don’t need to speak perfect English to do science. And there are job opportunities.

Define neuroethics.

It’s a kind of subspecialty of bioethics. Until very recently, the human mind was a black box. But here we are in the 21st century, and now we have all these new technologies with opportunities to look inside that black box — a little.

With functional magnetic imaging, f.M.R.I., you can get pictures of what the brain is doing during cognition. You see which parts light up during brain activity. Scientists are trying to match those lights with specific behaviors.

At the same time this is moving forward, there are all kinds of drugs being developed and tested to modify behavior and the mind. So the question is: Are these new technologies ethical?

A neuroethicist can look at the downstream implications of these new possibilities. We help map the conflicting arguments, which will, hopefully, lead to more informed decisions. What we want is for citizens and policy makers to be thinking in advance about how new technologies will affect them. As a society, we don’t do enough of that.

Give us an example of a technology that entered our lives without forethought.

The Internet. It has made us more connected to the world’s knowledge. But it’s also reduced our actual human contacts with one another.

So what would be an issue you might look at through a neuroethics lens?

New drugs to alter memory. Right now, the government is quite interested in propranolol. They are testing it on soldiers with post-traumatic stress disorder. The good part is that the drug helps traumatized veterans by removing the bad memories causing them such distress. A neuroethicist must ask, “Is this good for society, to have warriors have their memories wiped out chemically? Will we start getting conscienceless soldiers?”

What do you think?

It is a serious business removing memories, because memories can affect your personal identity. They can impact who you think you are. I’d differentiate between offering such a drug to every distressed soldier and giving it only to certain individuals with a specific need.

Let’s say you have a situation like that in “Sophie’s Choice,” where the memories are so bad that the person is suicidal. Even if the drug causes them to live in falsehood, that would have been preferable to suicide.

But should we give it to every soldier who goes into battle? No! You need memory for a conscience. Doing this routinely might create super-immoral soldiers. As humans we have natural moral reactions to the beings around us — sympathy for other people and animals. When you start to tinker with those neurosystems, we’re not going to react to our fellow humans in the right way anymore. One wonders about the wrong people giving propranolol routinely to genocidal gangs in places like Rwanda or Syria.

Some researchers claim to be near to using f.M.R.I.’s to read thoughts. Is this really happening?

The technology, though still crude, appears to be getting closer. For instance, there’s one research group that asks subjects to watch movies. When they look at the subject’s visual cortex while the subject is watching, they can sort of recreate what they are seeing — or a semblance of it.

Similarly, there’s another experiment where they can tell in advance whether you’re going to push the right or the left button. On the basis of these experiments some people claim they’ll soon be able to read minds. Before we go further with this, I’d like to think more about what it could mean. The technology has the potential to destroy any concept of inner privacy.

What about using f.M.R.I. to replace lie detectors?

The fact is we don’t really know if f.M.R.I.’s will be any more reliable or predictive. Nonetheless, in India, a woman was convicted of poisoning her boyfriend on the basis of f.M.R.I. evidence. The authorities said that based on the pictures of blood flow in her brain, she was lying to them.

Fin de l’article sur : http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/18/science/studying-ethical-questions-as-we-unlock-the-black-box-of-the-brain.html?_r=0


Cet article a reçu "1 commentaire"

  1. My pets blog dit :

    Hello! merci d’avoir partagé cet article et aussi toutes ces belles photos sur ton blog. je suis également passionné par les animaux et j’ai même débuté un blog y’a peu de temps. a bientôt, Julie

Un blog pour l’avenir

Non au futur (prévision froide). Oui à l'avenir (action humaine). Dixit le Petit Prince, "l'avenir, tu n'as pas à le prévoir, tu dois te le permettre".

Ce blog est dédié aux idées d'avenir positives, aux changements. La prospective est à la fois une science de synthèse pluridisciplinaire et un art pour défricher de nouveaux territoires, repérer des courants forces, explorer des imaginaires...

C'est surtout un outil Eureka pour inventer de nouveaux produits et services, sublimer ou mythifier une marque et ses produits, créer la valeur de la valeur....

Vive l'avenir, car ce qui est génial, c'est que tout commence et que tout est possible !


Contribuer à cet article :

Articles similaires

TO BE IA OR NOT TO BE ? Elon Musk veut nous améliorer en surhumains pour faire face à la méta intelligence de l’IA – mais est vraiment intelligent ?

avril 23, 2017

Voici un bref résumé traduit de la vision volonté d’Elon Musk d’ici 4 ans – Le reste de l’article sera en anglais – En bref je dirais que la question désormais serait TO BE IA OR NOT TO BE  .. ou d’autres voie possible ? Comme selon moi une intelligence collective (cerveau en commun) plus […]

Preparing for our posthuman future of artificial intelligence © David BRIN – un article fouillé qui pose de bonnes questions

mars 14, 2017

«Chaque génération s’imagine plus intelligente que celle qui l’a précédée, et plus sage que celle qui vient après». – George Orwell Que se passera-t-il lorsque nous entrerons dans l’ère de l’augmentation humaine, de l’intelligence artificielle et du gouvernement par algorithme? James Barrat, auteur de Our Final Invention, a déclaré: « La coexistence sécurisée et éthique avec […]

Le cerveau n’arrête jamais de grandir pendant toute la vie !

février 3, 2017

Une équipe du département de psychologie du Stanford Neuroscience Institute de l’Université de Stanford (Etats-Unis). Jusqu’à présent, il était admis que le cerveau cessait de se développer à l’âge adulte, même s’il continuait toute la vie à établir de nouvelles interconnexions entre neurones. Mais en couplant deux techniques d’imagerie, l’IRMf (fonctionnelle) qui visualise indirectement l’activité […]

Nanobots: The rise of the molecular machines (vidéo)

octobre 15, 2015

Video Source: American Chemical Society Nanomachines — including nano-sized motors, rockets and even cars — are many orders of magnitude smaller than a human cell, but they have huge promise. In the future, they could deliver drugs anywhere in the body, clean up oil spills and might even be used as artificial muscle cells. Find […]

Sortie de Nos robots, nous-mêmes: la robotique et les mythes de l’autonomie (Our Robots, Ourselves: Robotics and the Myths of Autonomy)

octobre 13, 2015

Un livre fouillé intéressant qui acte que  nous nous engageons sérieusement vers l’un des débats les plus importants de notre époque. et de notre humanité. – De drones vers Mars etc … ce livre offre une exploration de l’utilisation la plus innovante des robots aujourd’hui « enveloppé » d’un  argument provocateur pour le rôle crucial de l’homme […]